Sunday, June 27, 2021

Weekend Review: Small Bones

Small Bones / Vicki Grant
Victoria, BC: Orca, c2015.
239 p.

This novel is part of the Secrets series, a set of seven Canadian stories focused on, well, something secret.

I really enjoy Vicki Grant's writing (her other books have all been clever and funny)  -- and the main character in this book is a seamstress so it's a must read for me. 

In early June 1964, the Benevolent Home for Necessitous Girls is destroyed, in one fiery night. Each of the grown-up orphan girls (7 in all) are sent out to make their own way in the world -- thus the 7 titles in the series. This book follows Dorothy 'Dot' Blythe, nicknamed for her tiny size as an infant. She is searching for her origins, with one clue; a coat that she was wrapped in the night she was left on the orphanage's doorstep, with a label reading "Howell's of Buckminster". Her journey is brief; she leaves Hope, ON and takes a train to nearby-ish Buckminster, ON.

Once she arrives, however, she finds that an envelope that held all the money she had in the world has been stolen on the train. Desperate, she sees a notice for an employee needed at the Dunbrae Arms, a summer resort, which includes room & board -- so starts walking. And encounters a cute boy who was on the train as well, now on his bike and offering her a ride.

Their meeting is fortuitous for the plot, and also for the reader, as it is a very amusing scene. Grant's sense of the ridiculous in the everyday is in full swing here, and so there are many moments where I was laughing aloud, not at any slapstick comedy but at the situations and behaviours that Dot finds herself faced with.

There are definite period elements; the popular dance at the time is the twist, the trendy clothing that they wear is noted, there are post-war effects still felt in town, and of course, the biggest one of all, there is a reason that Dot's birth was kept a secret all this time. One more 60's element that I noticed is that Dot and her new boyfriend Eddie get pretty serious at the end; marriage is mentioned even though they are only 17ish. The way the plot wrapped up, all I could think was "how is she ever going to break up with him now?"

Despite the lightness and humour, Grant balances the secret of the story well, with tension and darkness involved. This is a youth-focused novel, however, and so she holds that line between the sadness of the past and the sense that Dot will prevail, and is not in too grave of danger. It's well done, amusing, charming, and appropriately tricky -- the reader won't figure out all the plot points very much faster than Dot finally does herself. It's a fun read, and other sewing readers will enjoy the stitching details, while anyone else will have a great time with the story & the way it is told.

(this review first appeared at The Indextrious Reader)


  1. I love the book review. My granddaughter, who is 10, is an avid reader. Would this be age-appropriate for her? Thank you.

  2. Hmm, not sure. It depends on her maturity level I think, easier for you to judge. But I think of it as a more 13+ kind of title, overall.


Share your comments, ideas or suggestions here -- I am always interested in hearing from readers. It's nice to have a conversation!